When to choose a disc screen to sort dry mixed and packaging waste

A multi-material collection stream is one of the more demanding inputs a material recovery facility (MRF) has to process. Bottles, cans, paper, film, large rigid plastics and glass arrive mixed in a single flow, spanning a wide range of both shapes and sizes, which is the core difficulty of separating mixed packaging waste.

For a plant designer specifying a new line, or a waste company assessing an upgrade to its MRF sorting equipment, one of the first decisions is which screening technology to adopt. Two are regularly compared for this task: the ballistic separator and the disc screen. The two do not do the same job: one separates by shape, the other by size, and understanding that difference is the first step to placing each at the right point in the line.

The two technologies at a glance

How does a disc screen work?

A disc screen separates material by size.  Ecostar’s DDS (Dynamic Disc Screening) technology uses a series of hexagonal or octagonal disc shafts made of Hardox, which impart a jolting motion to the material: undersize falls through the gaps between the discs while oversize advances along the deck.

The screening cut is set by the disc gap and the shaft speed, and can be adjusted ±30% in real time via inverter, across a range of 10 to 350 mm. To limit fibrous items winding around the shafts, the discs sit on high-strength free manifolds that turn independently of the shaft.

How does a ballistic separator work?

A ballistic separator uses a set of inclined, oscillating paddles that shake the incoming material. As Waste Today Magazine notes, a series of parallel paddles applies a strong shaking to the waste to achieve separation.

The motion splits the input into three streams:

  • flat, light items (2D fraction) such as paper, cardboard and film ride upward;
  • rounded, heavier items (3D fraction) such as containers and cans roll downward;
  • fine material drops through the perforations in the paddles.

Because separation is driven by shape and weight rather than a rotating screen, the machine has no shafts for material to wind around.

Disc screen vs ballistic separator: how is dry waste actually separated?

The core distinction between these two technologies is the sorting criterion:

  • The disc screen sorts by size, dividing undersized from oversized at an adjustable cut.
  • The ballistic separator sorts mainly by shape and density, dividing flat items (2D) from three-dimensional ones (3D) and from fines.

In a mixed waste stream, the two criteria work differently: the ballistic stage distinguishes a flat film from a rounded bottle, while the disc stage separates whatever sits above a set dimension from whatever passes below it. That difference decides where each machine adds value in a line.

Which screening technology handles film, bags and wrapping better?

Thin materials such as film, bags and plastic straps are the classic difficulty for any rotating screen, since they can wind around the shafts and force stops for cleaning; as Waste Today Magazine reports, wrapping materials such as ropes remain an acknowledged challenge across the sector.

A ballistic separator sidesteps the problem, having no rotating screening element. A disc screen addresses it mechanically: the free manifolds limit winding, and Ecostar’s HDDS (Hyper Dynamic Disc Screening) technology adds a special flap that hooks bags and filamentous materials before they wrap around the shafts and pushes them toward the oversize. The flap is designed for exactly the bags and plastic straps typical of packaging.

In a film-heavy stream, this is the feature that cuts stops for cleaning and keeps the line in production.

Stationary disc screens: flexibility and a smaller footprint

Ecostar screening systems for dry multi-material reach high throughput in a limited footprint. The screening cut can be changed on-site through the patented SWAT system (Screening Width Adjustment Technology): the operator adjusts the section quickly according to production needs and the material in the mix.

In a mixed waste screening line, where the input shifts with collection rounds and season, that adjustability sets how tightly a single machine can be matched to the target fraction, a concrete advantage when running a disc screen for mixed waste, where stream composition rarely stays constant. On a ballistic separator, the split depends largely on paddle angle and hole size, which are configurable but not usually varied in real time.

Summary comparison: stationary disc screen vs ballistic screen

The table below summarises the main characteristics of each technology based on typical operating conditions. Individual performance may vary significantly depending on the specific application and material.

Criterion Ballistic separator Disc screen (DDS/HDDS)
Separation principle Shape and density (2D / 3D + fines) Size (undersize / oversize)
Typical output 2D/3D split of packaging Sized fractions, fines removal
Handling of film and bags No rotating element to wind around Free manifolds plus HDDS flap
Screening-cut adjustment Set by paddle angle and hole size Adjustable ±30%, 10 to 350 mm
On-site cut change Limited Yes (SWAT)
Rotating screening parts None Discs on free manifolds

Ballistic separator vs disc screen: which technology fits your project?

When a line needs to give the material a precise size, the disc screen is built for the task: it removes fines, protects downstream equipment and produces set fractions such as the 50, 150, 200 and 300 mm cuts used in multi-material sorting.

The cut is tuned on-site as the input shifts by collection round and season, and the free manifolds with the HDDS flap keep film and bags in check where a traditional rotating screen would stall.

Conversely, when the priority is dividing a light, film-rich packaging stream into a 2D fraction and a 3D fraction, the ballistic separator is a natural fit, because it works on precisely that shape distinction and is unaffected by material winding around a shaft.

That said, in many mixed waste lines, these two technologies work together: disc screens for Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs) are the stage that sizes the flow, removes fines and protects downstream equipment, while the ballistic separator handles the 2D and 3D split. The practical question is less which single machine to choose and more what each stage of the line needs to achieve.

Ecostar disc screens for Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs)

For multi-material and mixed waste sorting, Ecostar uses disc screens with cuts of 50, 150, 200 and 300 mm, throughputs of 3 to 15 t/h and 7.5 kW motors. The range is built around two technologies, DDS technology (Dynamic Disc Screening) and HDDS (Hyper Dynamic Disc Screening, patented), with an anti-wrapping flap that handles bags and film and the patented SWAT system for changing the screening section on-site. Both are available across three machine lines: the stationary Hexact and the mobile Hextra and Nhexa. Compared with traditional disc screening, Ecostar disc screening cuts energy use by up to 70%.

Get in touch

For a specific application, the Ecostar technical team is available to advise on the right disc screen for mixed waste for your project: screening cuts, configuration and product line.